Based on: W. E. Davis and J. A. Jackson, editors. 2000. Contributions to the History of North American Ornithology. Volume 2. Memoirs of the Nuttall Ornithological club No. 13
- Julie Jedlicka (2022-2024)
- Valentina Ferretti (2020-2022)
- Dan Ardia (2018-2020)
- Paul G. Rodewald (2016-2018)
- Reed Bowman (2014-2016)
- Kathryn Purcell (2012-2014)
- L. Scott Johnson (2010-2012)
- David Bonter (2008-2010)
- Cecilia M. Riley (2006-2008)
- Eugene Morton (2004-2006)
- Scott Sutcliffe (2002-2004)
- Jerry Jackson (1999-2002)
- Charles Duncan (1997-1999)
- Elissa Landre (1995-1997)
- Gregory S. Butcher (1993-1995)
- Edward H. Burtt Jr. (1991-1993)
- Peter F. Cannell (1989-1991)
- William E. Davis, Jr. (1987-1989)
- John C. Kricher (1984-1987)
- George A. Clark, Jr. (1981-1984)
- Robert P. Yunick (1978-1981)
- James O. Seamans (1973-1978)
- John H. Kennard (1971-1973)
- James Baird (1967-1971)
- Charles E. Huntington (1962-1967)
- Edwin A. Mason (1956-1962)
- Charles H. Blake (1948-1956)
- Lawrence B. Chapman (1941-1947)
- Frederick A. Saunders (1935-1940)
- Laurence B. Fletcher (1930-1933)
- Francis Beach White (1928-1929)
- Francis H. Allen (1926-1927)
- Alfred O. Gross (1924-1925)
- Charles W. Townsend (1923)
- Edward H. Forbush (1922)